Borderlands 4 in 2026: Was It Really the Best Looter Shooter?

I still remember my first trip to Pandora. The guns, the jokes, the endless loot. Now it’s 2026, and Borderlands 4 has been out for a while. When the reviews first dropped in September 2025, they were overwhelmingly positive. Metacritic: 84. Open Critic: 87. That’s a clear step up from Borderlands 3, which sat at 81 and split the fanbase. It’s not quite enough to dethrone Borderlands 2 at 89, but it’s close. And after putting in dozens of hours myself, I think the real story is more interesting than a number.

The Scores Don’t Tell the Whole Story

Let’s get the numbers out of the way. Here’s how the mainline games stack up on Metacritic:

Game
Metacritic Score

Borderlands 2
89

Borderlands 4
84

Borderlands 3
81

On Open Critic, Borderlands 4 sits at 87. That’s a strong debut. It means Gearbox didn’t just avoid another Borderlands 3 situation—it actually won back a lot of trust. But scores are snapshots. The real question in 2026 is whether the game still feels great after the honeymoon phase. For me, it does. Mostly.

What Reviewers Loved

When the embargo lifted, some outlets went wild. XboxEra gave Borderlands 4 a perfect score. Reviewer Jesse Norris called it the best looter shooter he’s ever played. He said he had no major faults, only a few minor gripes—like how long bodies take to disappear when you want to grab the loot underneath them. Outside of that, he called it a masterpiece and said he could easily see himself putting in another thousand hours over the years.

DealNest

#game